A soft joint-limit penalty charged the standing pose itself - the geometric-zero knee sat on its hard limit, so stand_v1 bent its knees to dodge 0.419 per step and leaned 4.1 deg forward; excluding the knee gave 0.24 deg
soft-limit-penalty-charges-nominal-pose.Before training, evaluate every penalty at the nominal pose; if a joint's soft limit sits inside the pose the task requires (a straight knee on its hard stop), exclude that joint from the soft-limit penalty and let the action clip enforce the hard limit.
Symptom
stand_v1 (retrained after the default pose moved to the CAD geometric zero and mirror augmentation was added) fixed left/right asymmetry (6.8 -> 0.0 deg) but settled at a 4.1 deg forward lean, where pure PD at the same default settled at 0.1 deg - the policy was actively pushing itself forward, which is exactly the real robot's failure direction.
Context
soft_joint_pos_limit_factor = 0.9 shrank the knee's soft limit to -/+0.1047 rad, while the geometric-zero default has the knee at q = 0, exactly on the hard limit. Standing in the nominal pose therefore paid 0.2094 x 2.0 = 0.419 per step in dof_pos_limits (alive earned only 0.5). The policy's way out was to bend the knees to -/+0.1013 rad, and the cost was the forward lean.
Change
stand_v1b: the knees excluded from dof_pos_limits (a straight knee IS the standing pose; the hard limit is still enforced by the action clip). No other change.
Outcome
stand_v1b: max tilt 0.3 deg, steady tilt 0.24 deg, asymmetry 0.1 deg, height 0.384 m - exactly nominal - with knees at -0.0007 / +0.0005 rad. It became the standing release used on the real robot, and later the standing side of the recovery switch. The same exclusion was carried into the recovery contract (knee at the clip in the standing pose) and the one-leg reward table.
Mechanism
A limit penalty whose soft boundary lies inside the nominal pose turns the nominal into a taxed state, and the policy buys its way out with whatever posture change is cheapest - here a knee bend paid for with lean.
Applies when
- a standing or default pose has a joint at or near its hard limit
- a policy settles in a small steady tilt that pure PD does not show
- soft-limit factors shrink limits uniformly across joints
“`soft_joint_pos_limit_factor=0.9` 把膝软限位内缩到 ∓0.1047,而几何零位 default **膝盖 q=0 正好压在硬限位上** ⇒ 站在标称姿态每步白扣 `0.2094 × 2.0 = 0.419` (alive 才 +0.5)。策略只能屈膝到 ∓0.1013 躲罚,代价是躯干前倾 —— 恰好是真机的 失效方向。 … 修掉"软限位罚标称姿态"后重训(`dof_pos_limits` 排除膝盖)。**前倾问题彻底消失** … 不再屈膝躲惩罚,高度正好落回标称 0.3840。”